Begin at the centre and make your way outward. Settle on the family first,
asking yourself only whether what you have in the glass is wood, grain, sweetness, spice or
fruit, and move a ring further out once you feel sure of it. Most of us reach for the word
“vanilla” long before we have decided whether we are smelling sugar at all or simply
the oak it came out of.
WoodThis is the barrel speaking, and it speaks louder with the years and louder
still from the warm upper floors.
GrainHere is the mashbill making itself known. Rye offers pepper and dill, corn
lends its sweetness, and the malted barley brings something like fresh bread.
SweetVery nearly all of this comes from the char, where the wood's own sugars have
been caramelised by fire. Nothing whatever is added to a bourbon.
SpiceSome of it is the rye, some the tannin drawn out of the oak, and some is
nothing more than proof. Do try to tell the heat from the flavour before passing judgement.
Fruit & FloralThese are the esters, born in fermentation and coaxed along by
long years in the wood. They are also the first thing to disappear beneath water poured too
generously.
Nose it dry to begin with
Keep the mouth a little open, take short and easy
sniffs, and move the glass about rather than burying your nose in it. One long draw at barrel
proof will cost you the next three barrels.
Taste it twice over
The first sip is spent merely getting acquainted and will
tell you very little worth trusting. The second is the one to write down. Let it sit, work it
about the mouth until everything is coated, and only then swallow.
Then a little water
Two or three drops will serve, and never a pour. Water
opens up the fruit and the flowers and lays the heat down gently. Judge each barrel both ways
and make a note of which of them the water treats kindly.
Thomas T. Cooper · Barrel SelectionsFamilies after the common industry wheel; descriptors broadenedthomascooperselections.com