Thomas T. Cooper crest
Thomas T. Cooper · Barrel Selections

How a Barrel Pick Works

For first-timers
Read before you taste
Keep in your pocket

Nobody is going to ask whether you care for bourbon. The question put to you on the day is a gentler one: among three or four barrels that are every one of them good, which ought to carry the crest? That turns out to be an easier thing to answer than it sounds, and what follows is simply how an afternoon of it tends to unfold.

The shape of the day

They pull the samples

A copper thief is lowered into each barrel and drawn back up with a few ounces, and what it brings out is poured for you under nothing more than a letter. You will not be told which floor a barrel came from until the choosing is finished, which is a kindness rather than a secrecy, since a man who knows he is holding the top floor will taste the top floor whether or not it is in the glass.

You look

Hold the glass against something white and take the colour in without hurrying. A deeper amber generally speaks of more years, or of a berth higher in the rickhouse where the heat did more of its work. Take it as a hint about where the whiskey has been rather than a promise about how it will taste, for no bourbon ever drank better merely for being dark.

You nose, dry

Keep your mouth a little open and take short, easy sniffs with the glass moving rather than buried beneath your nose. These are poured at barrel proof, often somewhere between 115 and 130, and one long deep draw will leave you unable to smell much of anything for the next three barrels.

You taste, twice

The first sip is spent getting your palate acquainted with the proof, and it will tell you very little you ought to trust. The second is the one worth writing down. Let it sit a moment, work it around until it has coated everything, and then swallow.

You add water

Two or three drops will do, and never a pour. Water coaxes out the fruit and the flowers and takes the edge off the heat. Judge each barrel both ways and make a note of which one the water flatters, because most of us will be drinking it over an ice cube on a summer evening, and a barrel that falls apart under a little water is telling you something worth hearing.

You rank, not rate

Leave the numbers alone. Put the barrels in an order and say plainly why you placed them so. “C is the rounder of the two, A is the more interesting, and B is the one I would actually pour on a Tuesday evening” will serve the room far better than a score out of a hundred ever could.

The room decides

Then we talk it through, disagree amiably, and put it to a vote. The barrel that carries the day is the one most of us would be glad to pour for a friend, which is seldom the strangest barrel on the table and almost never the strongest.

Keeping your palate alive

  • Plain water at room temperature between every barrel, without fail.
  • Something plain to eat alongside, such as bread or a cracker. Nothing minty, nothing sweet, and no coffee.
  • Four barrels is about as far as an honest palate will carry you. By the sixth you are guessing, and the trouble is that you will not feel as though you are.
  • Leave the cologne at home, and try not to sit beside a man who did not.
  • There is no shame whatever in spitting. You will still be tasting properly when the fourth glass comes around, and the gentleman who did not will be taking your word for it.
  • Write your notes down as you go. By the time you reach the third barrel, your memory of the second has already been coloured by it.
The four honest traps
  • Strength wears the clothes of quality. A hot barrel makes the boldest first impression every time, though more often than not it is simply the loudest voice at the table.
  • Colour is a poor witness to age. It owes quite as much to where a barrel sat as to how long it sat there.
  • The first pour is favoured unfairly. Whichever barrel comes around first meets your freshest palate and gains an advantage it never earned, so go back and visit it again once you have been through them all.
  • Mind the pull of the room. Set your own notes down before anyone has said a word aloud. The first opinion spoken has a way of becoming everybody's, and it usually belongs to the most confident man present rather than the most careful one.
What it is we are buyingA single barrel will give up somewhere between a hundred and fifty and two hundred bottles, and once those are gone there is no making any more of them. That is rather the point of the whole business. We are not choosing a product from a shelf so much as choosing one barrel's particular account of a distillery, on one afternoon, and keeping it.

What to bring

Bring the scoring card and the flavour wheel from this set, a pen that is willing to write, and no settled opinions formed before the first pour. Everything else will be waiting for you.

Thomas T. Cooper · Barrel Selections Pair with the Barrel Scoring Card & the Flavour Wheel thomascooperselections.com