A good deal of what gets said about bourbon across a table is about half right, which is no great sin in pleasant company. Set down here is the portion of it that happens to be written down somewhere: what the federal rules actually require, what each grain brings to the glass, and why two barrels filled on the same morning from the very same run may taste nothing alike when you come back to them four years later.
“an alcoholic distillate from a fermented mash of any grain distilled at less than 95 percent alcohol by volume (190° proof)… stored in oak barrels… and bottled at not less than 40 percent alcohol by volume (80° proof).” 27 CFR 5.143 — the general class, “whisky”
The sternest claim a man may print on an American label, resting on the oldest consumer-protection standard in the country, the Bottled-in-Bond Act of 1897. One distiller, one distillery, one distilling season, four years at the least in a warehouse under federal supervision, and bottling at exactly 100 proof with nothing added but water.
“distilled in the same distilling season by the same distiller at the same distillery; stored for at least 4 years… reduced in proof by the addition of only pure water to 50 percent alcohol by volume.” 27 CFR 5.88
These carry a definition too, and a fairly recent one. A bottle may call itself barrel proof or cask strength only where the bottling proof sits no more than two degrees below the proof of the whiskey as it was dumped from the barrel. Almost nothing has been taken away, and what you pour is very near what the barrel gave up.
“the bottling proof is not more than two degrees lower than the proof of the spirits when the spirits are dumped from the barrels.” 27 CFR 5.87(a)
A label reading original proof, original barrel proof, original cask strength or entry proof makes a stricter claim still: that the proof going into the wood and the proof coming out into the bottle are one and the same.
Not defined anywhere in federal regulation. It is generally taken to mean the bottle came from one barrel and was never batched with its neighbours, which is precisely what we do, and it is why each of ours tastes unlike the last.
No definition whatsoever: no minimum, no maximum, no floor on age. One house will call four barrels a small batch and another will call it forty, so the phrase tells you rather more about the marketing than about the whiskey.
No definition either, nor any limit on what may be called limited. Six barrels and six thousand may both wear the phrase quite properly, and neither is obliged to say which it was.
| Corn | Rye | Wheat | Malt | What it tastes like | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Traditionallow rye | 70–78% | 8–15% | — | 10–15% | The familiar shape of the thing. Caramel and vanilla forward, a little spice at the back. Jim Beam and Wild Turkey both sit near 75 / 13 / 12. |
| High rye | 60–68% | 18–35% | — | 4–10% | Drier and leaner, with pepper and mint pushing through the sweetness. Bulleit runs 68 / 28 / 4; Four Roses' B bill goes to 35% rye. |
| Wheated | 68–75% | — | 15–20% | 10–15% | Wheat stands in for the rye entirely. Softer and rounder, more bread and honey than pepper — the bills that built the Pappy reputation. |
| Rye whiskeynot a bourbon | — | 51%+ | — | — | A different animal under the law: rye takes the majority instead of corn. Everything else about the barrel rules still applies. |
Ranges are what the houses commonly publish rather than anything the law requires. Only the 51% corn floor is a rule; the rest is a distiller's judgement, and the reason two bourbons can taste so little alike.
Maturation does the greater part of the work, more than the grain or the yeast or the still ever manage between them, and it does not go about that work evenly. A rickhouse is really a weather system with a roof over it. In a controlled trial at Bardstown, six identical barrels were set upon each of five floors and the whiskey analysed after twelve months.
Extraction of oak compounds, rising as you climb. The finding worth carrying away is not simply that the top of the house runs hotter, but that it swings further between hot and cold. It is that movement which drives the whiskey into the wood and draws it back out again, and the fourth and fifth floors, having the least shelter from the weather, swing hardest of all. Two barrels filled on the same morning and set five floors apart become two quite different whiskeys.
The Whisky Advocate scale, offered here for reference. We do not care to score our barrels out of a hundred. We put them in order against one another, that being the only question genuinely before us on the day.